Quantcast
Channel: Comments on: Talent Is Overrated, Deliberate Practice, & Tiger Moms [Book Review]
Browsing all 15 articles
Browse latest View live

By: J

Sounds a little like that Freakonomics book. Although, you have to figure most major athletes are practicing about the same amount with full-time coaches and some players are still just plain better...

View Article



By: JD

With athletes in certain sports those at the top may indeed devote the hours but I remember reading that max VO2 (Oxygen) uptake is highest in the best athletes. So for some top athletes it is genetic.

View Article

By: Mundo

Excellent article. The “deliberate practice” seems so obvious, but I ask myself where else have I plateau’d when I’m trying to accomplish anything in life, and I can see it everywhere at this point (my...

View Article

By: Jason

it is an very interesting perspective I would love to ask Earl Boykins (the shortest NBA player at 5-5) his thoughts on the book.

View Article

By: Jenna

Sounds a lot like Malcolm Gladwell’s Outliers, have you read it? Basically, you need thousands of hours of practice and the right opportunities to become great.

View Article


Image may be NSFW.
Clik here to view.

By: Jonathan

@J – Talent still matters, it’s just really overrated. If you turn on the TV and see an athlete, they worked an enormous amount of hours to get there. And that’s the major difference between them and...

View Article

By: Marie

Achievement is incredibly over-rated. Our culture has turned us into achievement-monkeys on a machine pushing and pushing harder because it furthers the needs of our society, not necessarily because...

View Article

By: Greg

I think people tend to forget about the thousands of hours athletes and musicians put into their trade… but talent still matters. A lot. Mozart’s sister started learning piano from the same obsessive...

View Article


By: Thuy

It is obvious that hard-work is required for achievement. That’s nothing new. But I don’t believe it’s available to everyone even if they are willing to pay the price. With hard work, you can turn poor...

View Article


By: ddelj

I played saxophone for eight years. Often several hours a day. I never became more that mediocre. On the other hand I was the best sprinter in my HS. That I practiced very little. I don’t want to knock...

View Article

By: Jenna

@Jonathan – Wow? Did you just add that in or did I completely miss a paragraph?

View Article

Image may be NSFW.
Clik here to view.

By: Jonathan

@Jenna – It was in the original post, but it’s a long post so I understand.

View Article

By: Jiah

I agree with Marie above. I think fun/enjoying life is so under-rated. Mozart is not Mozart because he practiced a lot, but because he has an ability to enjoy tirelessly vigorous practice. I appreciate...

View Article


By: Eric

The Amy Chua excerpt was completely misleading. The actual book was very thought provoking. I recommend reading it for the full picture.

View Article

Image may be NSFW.
Clik here to view.

By: Alain

Both genetics and practice influence performance. What science is “recently” finding is that to achieve an expert level of performance, practice is more important than genetics. Genetical...

View Article

Browsing all 15 articles
Browse latest View live




Latest Images